Mississippi Hunting and Fishing Forums banner

How do you fry your fish?

3791 Views 15 Replies 13 Participants Last post by  Outrider
What do you use for batter? Any secret recipes for the batter?
What temp do you cook crappie?
What is your favorite oil?

Same questions for Catfish and bream. I realize the smaller the filet the shorter the cooking time. Planning on cooking some crappie on the 4th and would like it to turn out excellent.
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
I have tried the prepackaged batters before but always return to plain yellow cornmeal, salt, pepper and Tony's. No real measurement, just eyeball it.

I like to cook at 375 with peanut oil.

I always baste my fish with Louisiana Hot Sauce and a little Mustard about 20 minutes before they hit the batter. I also ALWAYS leave them in the refrigerator until they go straight to the batter and then the fryer. I never batter more than one batch (10 pieces or so) at a time. I found if the batter sits on the fillet too long it will get mushy.

This is just the way I do it.
I agree its hard to beat regular corn meal but we all love the zatarain's southern crispy fish fry. Its got a hint of lemon in it and is delicious.
Here is a healthier alternative to deep frying. It works best for really thin fillets.

Salt and pepper your fillets an hour ahead of cooking and let them sit in the refridgerator. When you get ready to cook them, put a small amount of mayonaise in a bowl (maybe a half tsp or so per fillet is all it takes). Using a pastry brush, brush the fillets with mayo on both sides. (the reason for pre-staging the mayo in the bowl is so that you don't contaminate the jar of mayo with the brush). Roll the fillets in seasoned bread crumbs (my favorite is italian seasoned with romano cheese). You don't want a heavy coating - just enough to stick to the fish. Mayo is basically oil and egg so it will melt as soon as it hits the pan. It is just used to make the crumbs stick.

Get a pan medium hot and add a little bit of oil - just enough to make a wet surface. I use grapeseed oil because it has all the health benefits of olive oil but has the high-smoke point of peanut oil. HERE IS THE KEY - only turn the fillets one time because you'll break them if you aren't gentile. With a thin fillet (like a flounder) it only takes about 2 minutes on the first side and even less on the other.

Be ready to plate and serve as soon as they get done because they'll cool off fast.
See less See more
I don't fry fish a lot any more but, here's my starting point, as I do things different all the time. Same for deer steaks, but I'll do an egg wash (if anything) instead of mustard.

2 cups corn meal
1/2-1 cup flour
Salt/Pepper to taste
Season to taste (I'm hook on Slap Ya Mama cajun seasoning right now)
Put fish in ziploc bag and coat lightly with mustard of choice
Mix well and dredge fish through meal/flour mixture and deep fry
Peanut oil
About 360
Uncle Bucks seasoning at Bass Pro, I like the spicy
For frying I coat my fillets with yellow mustard and a little hot sauce and let sit for 30 minutes in the fridge and coat enough to fry one batch at a time using Zatarains. I use a paper bag or plastic whatever is handy for my meal and dust it pretty good with cavendars and a little pepper. I like peanut oil and 350-375. Before serving I hit them with fresh squeezed lemon
Like redspeckable, I use mustard and a little beer to wet batter them first. Dang I'm hungry now
For frying I coat my fillets with yellow mustard and a little hot sauce and let sit for 30 minutes in the fridge and coat enough to fry one batch at a time using Zatarains. I use a paper bag or plastic whatever is handy for my meal and dust it pretty good with cavendars and a little pepper. I like peanut oil and 350-375. Before serving I hit them with fresh squeezed lemon
This ^ Great minds think a like or I guess I should say great stomachs think a like even if yours is a little bigger.[biggrin]
Zatarain's 350° and like others only batter enough for one batch at a time. Also find that it helps if the fillets are not dripping wet before you batter them. Sometimes I like to do the mustard before coating in fish fry. The oil I like to use is a blend of peanut and soybean oil. I think it's called southern frying oil. Not as expensive as peanut oil and lasts a while.

I also like to do something similar to what DoyleAlley posted. Not quite as healthy as his version but much better than frying.

2 eggs (beaten)
3/4 cup bread crumbs (I like italian panko best)
1/4 cup parmesan cheese
salt
pepper
garlic
tony's (or favorite cajun seasoning)
thyme
REAL butter

Beat the eggs in one bowl, mix bread crumbs and seasons in another. Heat pan over med heat. Dip fillets in eggs then coat with seasoned bread crumbs. Melt about a tablespoon of butter in the hot pan and brown each side of fillets turning only once. Sometimes a small amount of butter needs to be added when you flip the fillets.

Just keep an eye on the heat. The butter will burn easy if it is too hot. After you cook the first batch, wipe pan clean with wad of paper towels and repeat until all of fish is cooked. I usually have two pans going to be able to cook enough for all 4 of us. You have to work fast though. It only takes a couple minutes.
See less See more
In the spirit of this thread, I thought I'd share. I was prepping a deer roast last night and got a call out of the blue from a buddy, asking if I wanted some bass. Of course I said "heck yea" if they're fileting size! He brought over a garbage sack full of about twelve 3-4lb. Bass, straight from one of Oxford's private managed lakes! Those well-fed footballs produced close to 5 lbs. of filets. I will be trying some of the above techniques. [cool][drool]

See less See more
Those are the perfect sized thickness for what I was talking about. Yum.
I've watched my Dad fry fish for years and his recipe/preparation has never changed. Whether the fillets are from the freezer or fresh, he puts them in a strainer and drains as much of the water off of them as possible. Then, he lays the fillets out on paper towels and also pats them dry with paper towels. He has always stressed to me to get them as dry as possible. Once they're dry, he shakes them in plain yellow corn meal with salt. As far as the temp, I've never saw him use a thermometer but I'd bet it's around 350-375.

As for the drying the fillets before you meal them, if you like a thin coating with not so much crunch it's the way to go!
This ^ Great minds think a like or I guess I should say great stomachs think a like even if yours is a little bigger.[biggrin]
Hey got to keep the ribs from showing [biggrin]
flour , black pepper, canola oil . 325-350 degrees .
Cooking fish

Don't deep fry much any more. Lightly salt fish fillets on both sides, then sprinkle on your favorite seasoning ( I use Tony S lite or Cavenders). Generously spray the bottom of a black skillet with Pam or other vegetable spray and turn on medium heat. Toss in fillets. Turn them several times while cooking to avoid sticking. Cook until meat is bright white and will flake off with a fork. Serve and enjoy. Catfish or Tilapia fillets go well with most anything, but a good option for me is accompany them with well- peppered stir-fried cabbage, good tartar sauce, rolls and off course, iced tea. That combination will put an old guy to sleep in a recliner.
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top